“There will be oil”, the Wall Street Journal headline reads. The CERA professor is triumphant in his article. “For decades, advocates of ‘peak oil’ have been predicting a crisis in energy supplies. They’ve been wrong at every turn.” He predicts a plateau, beginning around 2050, with as much as 110 mbd produced by 2030. He adds a caveat: this is not a “done deal” because of geopolitics. Strong critiques by ASPO experts follow: by Jean Laharrere in Le Monde, by Kjell Aleklett on his own website, by Euan Mearns on The Oil Drum.